KZTimer Official Maplist - A New And Better System

Discussion in 'Announcements' started by Kenneth, Aug 15, 2015.

By Kenneth on Aug 15, 2015 at 1:00 AM
  1. Kenneth

    Kenneth KZ-Climb.com Founder Staff Member

    Joined:
    Jan 20, 2015
    Messages:
    624
    Likes Received:
    303
    A New System

    Currently, as soon as a map with proper Timers is played with KZTimer plugin, it is uploaded into KZTimer's global database. KZTimer will potentially switch to a system where new maps are not automatically registered for the global database, but are approved manually.

    Higher Quality Maps, Better KZ Experience

    We have currently reached a point where many new maps are being released every week. However, not all of them are on par with the quality that you usually expect. By filtering out the maps that are low-quality, we believe that this will improve the general KZ experience.

    A More Organized Community

    The hope for this new system is to make the entire KZ CSGO community more organized. Up until now, there has never been an official KZ maplist. Different KZ servers had different KZ maps - server owners lacked direction in what maps to upload onto their servers. Some server owners chose to upload all map regardless of quality, some chose to upload only the ones they deemed favorable. This change hopes to fix this problem. Of course - server owners still have the choice of uploading their personal favorite maps regardless of whether it is approved or not, but now they have direction into what general maps are high quality.

    Introducing the Workshop System

    The KZTimer Official Map List will be published as a Workshop Collection. This is helpful in many ways:

    • Fixes the Missing .bsp error, which is due to different versions of the map sharing the same filename.
    • Map is hosted onto Steam's CDN, eliminating the need for server owner to set up a FastDL server
    • Players can instantly download all KZ maps by simply subscribing to the Workshop collection
    • Server owners can subscribe their servers to the Workshop collection, automatically updating their server whenever a new map is released
    • In the server browser, players have the ability to right click on the map and click "View in workshop" to find out more information about it. This easily provides means to find information about the map, such as its description, screenshots, who the map maker is, or when the map was published.
    • In the Workshop system, map makers can easily update their map. Anyone, or any server, subscribed to the KZTimer Official Map List will have the map updated too.


    Beneficial to Map Creators Too

    KZTimer Map Testers will always provide helpful feedback to map creators to improve their maps. In addition, we will provide map creators with a private server so they can freely test by themselves too. Getting feedback on a new map has never been easier.

    A Map Testing Team

    A map testing team has been carefully selected to contain outstanding members of the community who share a love for KZ. They have years of experience playing KZ, and has an appreciation for KZ maps as well as the map making process.

    Every Saturday, an administrator of this Map Tester group will send a list of Workshop maps for testers to test. For every map, they must answer the following questions:

    1. Do you think that the map maker has spent a lot of effort in making the map high quality, and why?
    2. Do you think that this map will be enjoyed by general KZ population, and why? Do you think that there is a role or niche that this map fulfills that a small group of people might enjoy and would be interested in having it be global?
    3. Do you think that there is interest in having a global record for the map for competition, and why?
    4. General feedback (parts you liked, parts you did not like, shortcuts or skips, what you think will improve the map, etc)
    5. Do you approve of this map being on the global database (yes or no)?

    Each player will test the maps by themselves, so they can go at their own pace, and so that there is no confirmation bias

    Maps having an approval rate of 50% or above will be activated in the global database. Map creators receive feedback from the questionaire either way, and have as many chances to re-submit newer versions of the map as they want.

    Every Sunday, an administrator will add approved maps to the KZTimer Official Map List, and provide an updated mapcycle.txt for server owners.

    An Official Tier/Difficulty List

    In addition to approving new maps, the map testing team will also be responsible for judging the difficulty of each map. Difficulty Lists has been in beta testing for several months at KREEDZ EUROPE server and is expected to be adopted in the official KZTimer Global as well. This will be very helpful to newer players who are not yet familiar with all KZ maps.

    Automatic Updating Servers

    One of the big goals for all of this is for servers to automatically update by themselves. The official KZTimer Official Map List using the Steam Workshop Map Collection framework plays a very big role in this, as it helps subscribed server automatically update its map files. The second big part is configuring servers to automatically update its mapcycle.txt based off the Official Map List - this will let players nominate new maps or else they will never see the light of day. In the coming KZTimer v1.75 update, we will provide instructions on how to configure this.
     
    pano likes this.
Tags: this article has not been tagged

Comments

Discussion in 'Announcements' started by Kenneth, Aug 15, 2015.

    1. GreatWarrior
      GreatWarrior
      awesome! hopfully this removes the <20 sec maps on the global list...
    2. kaldren
      kaldren
      seems like this could be a good thing. There are a ton of maps that just shouldn't be in the rotation because of a variety of reasons. How many people are in the map tester list though? will there be a broad enough basis to ensure maps of all styles have fair shots?
    3. JWL
      JWL
      @kaldren There are currently 13 people involved in the KZTimer Map Testers group. It's been working out decently so far, and the list is essentially ready for the 1.75 update. The group is currently comprised of mostly server owners and a few longtime players (like 8bo), but the roster is subject to change.

      It's definitely a good thing, and the goal is to remove broken/bad maps while holding mapmakers to a better quality standard.
    4. kaldren
      kaldren
      @JWL yeah, i know that HoC had a testing group, and i always thought it was a good idea. Would just suck if some of the favorites of some players dont make it in to a final map pool. For instance, one of my absolute favorite maps to run is kz_redemption. It has quite a few shortcuts though, which really doesnt detract anything from my experience, but would it be cut because it has some big shortcuts? I love the idea for a lot of shitty maps. I think maps that dont make it should be posted up as to why they were not chosen, and maybe give the community a chance to see that. how many of the testers are mapper too? just curious.
    5. kaldren
      kaldren
      also, i guess i asked the last question, moreso because if there are certain issues keeping a map from being chosen that a mapper might know can be fixed, is there going to be a way for mappers to revise their map to be tested again?
    6. JWL
      JWL
      @kaldren None of the decisions are concrete. Any map that is removed/rejected can be added with changes. For example, kz_synergy_ez/x are set to be removed from globals, however, @MachineChaos has ported newer versions with map-breaking crouch-hop skip edited out. As far as giving the community a chance to see which maps are being rejected/chosen, you'll need to talk to @Kenneth about that. Finally, a few of the testers are mappers, but I don't know how many. If you have anymore questions, feel free to add me on Steam, as I'm currently accepting all friend requests atm. Even the weird ones. And the bots. The Russians. The Brazilians. The people who are evidently my brother.
    7. kaldren
      kaldren
      @JWL ok cool, I am just curious about it all. I haven't released a map since january, but i'm starting to get the bug again, so im going to be making some stuff. Granted, i usually try to put as much time into a map as i can, still is nice to have a good outline of how everything is going to be done. Would hate for myself, or another mapper to put in countless hours to just have their map thrown out and not played on any server without being told why. I'll add you too though, im not sure if we have ever had the chance to play together!
    8. Kenneth
      Kenneth
      @kaldren The roster will be made public when KZTimer v1.75 gets released in a few days. We have a good variety of experienced testers of all skill levels, who have an appreciation for the map creation process.

      More information on the process and how to submit maps will be given when v1.75 comes out too. The process is meant to be as helpful to map creators as possible. If a map is rejected, the map creator will get detailed feedback from every single member of the team on the reasons why. The reason will never be something stupid such as "the map is too hard for most people". Map makers also have an infinite number of tries to update his map and re-submit, and we will always welcome it.
    9. GorillaGrodd
      GorillaGrodd
      Sounds cool, finally a fix for the missing map errors

Share This Page